Doctor Who’s Future in Jeopardy Amid Viewer Backlash and Disney+ Uncertainty
LONDON – The fate of Doctor Who, one of Britain’s most cherished television series, hangs in the balance as viewing figures continue to decline and industry insiders speculate on whether the long-running show will be rested indefinitely.
The controversy surrounding the BBC’s decision-making took another turn when Ncuti Gatwa, the 31-year-old actor portraying the Time Lord, abruptly withdrew from presenting the UK’s jury votes at last week’s Eurovision Song Contest. His decision came amid ongoing debate over Israel’s inclusion in the event, sparking disappointment among BBC executives.
Declining Popularity and Shifting Storylines
Doctor Who has faced criticism in recent seasons over narrative choices that some fans feel alienated longtime viewers. The introduction of complex social themes, including non-binary alien characters and storylines centered on incels, has left portions of the audience disengaged.
Despite high expectations when Gatwa was announced as the Doctor alongside his companion Ruby Sunday (played by Millie Gibson), ratings have plummeted. Some episodes attracted as few as 1.6 million viewers—far from the show’s peak of 10 million during the tenures of David Tennant and Matt Smith.
Insiders claim the disappointing reception could put the BBC’s lucrative partnership with Disney+ in jeopardy. The streaming giant reportedly invested heavily in the franchise, yet its future renewal remains uncertain.
As speculation mounts, some BBC executives are reportedly considering a temporary hiatus for the show—a decision that could allow time to recalibrate its creative direction. A source familiar with discussions stated, “It’s unlikely we will see who Ncuti regenerates into, as the BBC wants to keep all options open. If they do rest the show for years, casting a successor now becomes virtually impossible.”
The BBC, however, remains officially noncommittal. A spokesperson reiterated: “The decision on season three will be made after season two airs, and any other claims are pure speculation. The deal with Disney+ included 26 episodes, and we still have an entire spin-off, ‘The War Between the Land and the Sea,’ to release.”
A Legacy at Crossroads
Doctor Who has long been considered a cultural institution in the UK—one that once captivated global audiences. Its struggles highlight broader concerns about evolving audience expectations and the difficulties faced by legacy franchises seeking to balance tradition and modernization.
If the BBC does put the show on ice, future creative custodians may ultimately determine whether the Doctor can regain their standing among sci-fi enthusiasts or remain a distant memory of British television history.
